Re: Major CAS Art Theft!!!!
Posted by:
garymorris (IP Logged)
Date: 20 August, 2006 06:23PM
I'm with Boyd on this one. CAS's sculptures are pretty intriguing as examples of a kind of neo-pre-Colombian (there's a mouthful) style. But the drawings, while mildly atmospheric, have nowhere near the impact of his stories. They're personal enough and sufficiently otherworldly to resemble "outsider art" but overall seem primitive, and not in the good way! The landscape paintings I find a little more interesting, but again they're ultimately nothing special.
I remember being surprised at Lovecraft's enthusiasm for Smith's quite crude drawings illustrating an HPL story ("The Lurking Fear" in Home Brew, I think). I suspect it was HPL's kindliness and friendship, rather than hia true aesthetic judgment, that prompted the praise. John Vetter has some interesting comments on this artwork in his article "Lovecraft's Illustrators" in The Dark Brotherhood.
I believe it would be hard for anyone who didn't know the artist's identity to connect Smith's art, particularly the drawings, with his incomparable fiction.