walrus Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> STJ now has a review of the book linked from his
> blog: [
stjoshi.org]
If you read the review carefully, and sift out all the indignation, you can see that Joshi actually admits that Luckhurst's text follow (via Derleth's editions) HPL's final instructions, while his own texts include material from early drafts that HPL never even submitted for publication.
An more-extended analysis of Joshi's review is posted here on google groups:
[
groups.google.com]