Jojo Lapin X Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I was thinking of the notes.
>

Well, he obviously wasn't going to do any original research, so it was either STJ or LSdC.

L Sprague de Camp annotated Lovecraft? Surely not.

You lost me when you compared Joshi to Mabbott. It's akin to comparing an ant to an elephant.

Absquatch Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> You lost me when you compared Joshi to Mabbott.
> It's akin to comparing an ant to an elephant.

I am not making a comparison in quality, merely pointing out the analogy concerning their continued interest and publication each on a particular figure....

However, as Joshi's own ideas concerning HPL continue to evolve (which they certainly do in various respects), I still maintain that he has more of interest to add on that subject....

As in other areas, we'll simply have to agree to disagree, re. Joshi, Mabbott, etc. I definitely prefer not to resume the pro- or anti-Joshi debate, which was, as I recall, thoroughly covered in another thread.