Re: Less Familiar Weird Literature
Posted by:
Knygatin (IP Logged)
Date: 16 February, 2013 07:09PM
"The Beckoning Fair One", my first one by Oliver Onions. Very intelligent. Almost too perfect. For university students of ghostology, this story could well serve as the study foundation. If one reads it attentively, it chills the bones; I nearly, just nearly, had a synthetic nervous breakdown from it.
The first half is especially good. The second half is somewhat a letdown, turning it into sad tragedy. Nevertheless, an excellent account of a man's gradual descent into madness.
The drip of the tap water and its follow-up consequence, I thought was the best account of ghostliness. It is more than ambiguity, for it works as actual proof of ghostly happenings - and yet is too subtle for anyone to grab at afterwards for sustaining evidence. That's how ghosts (or other visiting spirits) work, they give you undeniable evidence, but nothing of it will remain for you to convince other people with.
The subtle sound of 'hair combed' was also a good effect. And the 'forgotten nail' was ok too.
However, Onions lost it a bit, I felt, with the 'hovering comb'. That was too coarse. Ghosts don't do telekinesis, or break Natural physic laws - instead they flow with it, manipulating subtly.
The story felt too conventional in subject for me. It fell short of genius, even though very intelligent and insightful.
Oliver Onion's own private person was quite attractive, manly, good-looking. A normal functioning man, surely well regarded and respected. (I guess he had some hidden hang-ups though, to write such a story.) I generally prefer ugly, or oddly unsymetric looking, writers. Their fiction is often more perverted and imaginative - in their obsessive efforts to build up an alternative world, to compensate for the deficiency in their personal lives. Oliver Onions is more a guy I would like to have had as a psychiatrist, when I'm really miserable.
I will try a few more of his stories. But not right now.
I have a reading-list of 56 ghost story writers, I have not read before. Yes sir, fifty-six unique individuals, waiting on my book-shelf. 56 mustachioed Victorian gentlemen writing ghost stories; Well, that's not exactly true, a few of them are women.
But now I will read something completely different. My first book by Arthur C. Clarke, The City and the Stars. My instinct tells me it will be splendid. It is set in the extremely remote future, and reputedly full of weird and novel concepts.