Re: Tales Of India And Irony
Posted by:
The English Assassin (IP Logged)
Date: 15 December, 2011 04:54AM
That's really rubbish that those who subscribed get their copy a month or so after the rest of us have put it on the shelf after reading it. I thnk NSB have treated subscribers terribly!
If this vol doesn't excite, then it shouldn't be bought, it's as simple as that - unless you are a completest... So stop moaning. It's there if you want it, if not...
Personally, I loved it. No, it's probably not all essential, but the inclusion of Infernal Star and the Dead will Cuckold You, along with his 'ironic' tales make it a great buy. Maybe if I'd already read Infernal and Cuckold I might feel differently, as I can take of leave his 'Indian' tales (bar one). The alt version of 'Hashish Eater' is also a nice inclusion. Also, although I've read it before, it is always a pleasure to re-read the 'Sorcerer Departs.' A truly beautiful essay.
My only complaint would be that I'd argue that both Infernal and Cuckold are so good that they really deserve to be included in the Collected Fantasies rather than sidelined into this companion edition. Okay, one's incomplete and the other is a play, but to my mind both represent CAS at his very best! Certainly any 'greatest hits' or 'selected works' worth its salt has to include both (along with the best of his verse).
I do have a question for Scott & Ron or any other CAS scholar here who knows: is their any clue as to how Infernal Star might have ended?
Also, has no one been tempted to have a go at completing the tale themselves? And if so, just for fun, which author does anyone think could achieve the best results? Gene Wolff, maybe? Jack Vance might have been good...
Also, at the risk of appearing a little foolish, why are his 'ironic' tales called so? Is it because they are ironic in their rhetoric technique or because there is a certain poetic irony to the just deserts dished out in the narrative or is it a reference to romantic irony: that CAS's attitude to them and the genre was ironic as he considered the genre to be in inferior? Or a mix of all three? As I think they all could apply... Did CAS Christen them 'tales of irony' or did that come later?